Alright.
I guess I have to be the one to say it.
Are we really doing this again?
Because I swear we have seen this movie before.
Scratch that. We’ve seen this movie several times.
And this isn’t a movie you put on when you want to unwind.
It’s not even a movie you turn for background noise when you have chores to do.
No, my friends.
This is a movie that is stuck on your television screen when your 1-year-old hides the remote and you can not change the channel.
It’s a joke.
And it’s not funny anymore.
The Detroit Tigers spend weeks giving us just enough reason to believe there might be something here. A young player has a breakout game. Riley Greene starts looking like Riley Greene again. Kevin McGonigle starts hitting the baseball into places where baseballs are not supposed to go.
And just when you think, “Okay…maybe there’s something to build on here…”
WHAM.
We drop another series.
We slip further into oblivion.
Are we really doing this again?
The Tigers entered the week coming off a four-game series in Cleveland in which they lost three times—all of those by walk-off. Detroit then returned home Monday and beat Minnesota 5-4, because apparently the Tigers wanted to give us hope again.
Then Tuesday night happened.
The Tigers lost to Minnesota 3-2.
Kevin McGonigle hit another two-run homer—his second homer in as many games—but that accounted for all of Detroit’s offense. The Tigers managed only five hits, and after briefly taking a 2-1 lead in the fifth, they watched Kody Clemens hit a two-run homer in the sixth to put Minnesota back in front.
And that was it.
Three runs.
Five hits.
Another loss.
The Tigers are now 66-79.
And with just 17 games remaining, we’re long past the point where pretending this is still primarily about the playoff race makes much sense.
Which brings us to the real question.
What are we watching for now?
It doesn’t seem like it but there are reasons to watch.
Kevin McGonigle is becoming increasingly difficult to ignore.
The rookie has now homered in consecutive games, and his two-run shot Tuesday accounted for every Detroit run. He’s hitting .273 and has 16 home runs on the season.
That’s something.
Riley Greene is something.
After going through a prolonged stretch without a home run, Greene has suddenly found the power stroke again. Monday’s blast against Minnesota was his third homer in three games.
That’s something too.
And maybe that’s what the final few weeks of this season need to be about.
Not pretending the Tigers are secretly one hot streak away from October.
Not pretending everything is fine.
And definitely not pretending another 3-2 loss is somehow encouraging.
Instead, let’s figure out who belongs here.
Who is part of the next good Tigers team?
Who isn’t?
What do you have in Riley Greene?
What do you have in McGonigle?
What do you have in Max Clark?
What do you have in the pitching?
What do you have in the bullpen?
And perhaps most importantly…
What the hell happened to this team?
Because this wasn’t supposed to be the year where we’re asking those questions again.
Yet here we are.
Again.
The Tigers have spent much of 2026 reminding us that baseball is a cruel sport. They’ll give you a great comeback, then blow a lead. They’ll lose a heartbreaking game, then come out the next day and look fantastic.
They’ll make you believe.
Then they’ll make you regret believing.
Then they’ll win a game just when you’ve finally decided you’re done caring.
And then you’ll watch the next game anyway.
Because you’re a Tigers fan.
That’s how they get you.
So, yes…
Are we really doing this again?
Apparently.
But here’s the difference this time:
I’m not asking whether the Tigers are going to make the playoffs.
I’m asking a much more important question.
Give me something to believe in for 2027.
That’s what these last few weeks should be about.
Find the kids.
Find the answers.
Find the pieces.
And please, for the love of baseball…
Give us a reason to come back next year.
Comments